One of the
most popular articles on our site has been Xbox vs. PS2. It was written over a
year ago by Matt Baldwin, who is still a part of GamesFirst! At that time the PS2 had not
launched and the Xbox was a long way off. Information was sketchy, but Matt felt strongly
about his position. I am happy to report that Matt has now completely changed his opinion
and is now a big GameCube supporter. This is the way the video game world goes you
never really know anything until you can play. And thats why Im writing this
editorial. Ive been bombarded in the past few weeks with letters asking which is
better, Xbox or PS2. So here is one mans opinion. Feel free to disagree. I genuinely
think that it will be hard to go wrong with either of the three next generation systems.
Ill make this easy on you, the reader, and come right out
with it: Xbox rules. The PlayStation 2 is simply an inferior system. It has inferior
hardware, put together in a completely bizarre configuration with utter disregard for the
standards that have arisen to govern computer system design. There is not nearly enough
memory in the system. The Emotion Engine is some wacky processor that doesnt really
mean anything to most folks familiar with hardware. It has no hard drive and no network
connectivity. Sure, these things are coming, but who wants to upgrade their console
system? Didnt you PS2 owners already pay $300 for the system? Why should you have to
invest more just to get up to par. Hands down, the PS2 is the least technically impressive
system. GameCube and Xbox have it beat with no contest. These are not debatable points
they are facts.
The Xbox has an excellent hardware configuration. A 700 Mhz Intel processor combined
with buttloads of system RAM and a GeForce 3 equivalent Nvidia graphics processor all come
together to make the Xbox comparable to most decent gaming PCs right now. That power is
amplified over the power of a PC with similar hardware because of the integrated system
architecture. Some folks have thought of the Xbox as a PC in a funny box, which turns off
many console gamers. Rather, you should think of the Xbox as a conceit that game
developers can buy into. And its a mistake if you think the Xbox is simply geared
towards satisfying console gamers this sucker is going to sway PC gamers to the
darkside, too. The ethernet card built into the Xbox will be used next year to facilitate
broadband gaming. As anyone who games online already can tell you, there is no other way
to go except broadband. Currently, the network adapter is useful for hooking Xbox units
together and hosting the most amazing LAN bashes around. The piece de resistance is
definitely the hard drive. Weve needed one of those for so long, and nobody seemed
to know it. The hard drive removes the need for memory cards, although the system does
support those so you can tote your save data to a friends house. But you dont
need one of the little suckers. At 10GB, the hard drive has plenty of room to save game
files for ages, even archive them. In addition, you can insert a music CD, rip songs to
your Xbox hard drive, then tell your games to play your music when you tire of the game
music. Even though games like Amped feature over 100 songs on the soundtrack, this is a
great feature.
Of course, one of the hardware aspects of the system that gets bashed is the DVD
playback. You must buy a DVD Playback Kit, which is basically a remote control for your
Xbox and will set you back about $30, in order to watch movies. Granted, the PS2 does this
out of the box, although most folks I know who use their PS2s to watch movies have
invested in a wireless remote so they dont have to use the controller. The systems
are about comparable in the quality of DVD playback, although it should be noted that the
Xbox is already using the DVD format for their games, while only a few titles have done so
on the PS2 (and did The Bouncer really need to be on a DVD?).
The superiority of
the Xbox hardware is best conveyed in the superiority of the system menu and navigation.
The PS2 was pretty snazzy when we first saw it, but the Xbox configuration and menu system
is just phenomenal. Its one of the coolest interfaces Ive seen in a long time,
and its much more intuitive than the PS2s menu system. This is a small factor,
and shouldnt really make a difference in which system you choose, but it seems
emblematic of the superior hardware and design qualities of the Xbox.
The next most popular thing to email me about is graphics. Which is better, Xbox or
PS2? Well, the Xbox, duh. I mean, the PS2 is working with hardware that is over two years
old (dont forget that the graphics processor was designed well before the system
released), while the Xbox uses a modified GeForce 3 card, which is the standard for PC
gaming RIGHT NOW. Sure, amazing things can be done with the PS2, and future generations of
PS2 games will look great, but the Xbox has more potential to reach a higher top end of
graphics quality. The Xbox is just more powerful and provides more opportunities for
developers. Beyond the constraints of hardware, it is up to developers to make pretty
games. So youll see some Xbox titles that dont look as good as PS2 titles, but
the potential is there to far outpace PS2 games. This is evident in launch titles like
HALO, Munchs Oddysee, DOA3 and Project Gotham. These games look gorgeous. Even games
that dont look so great, such as Azurik, feature amazing lighting, particle and
shadow effects that are just obviously better than anything weve seen on PS2. It is
impossible to say that one or the other system will always feature better graphics, but it
looks like the Xbox has the PS2 beat in this arena.
What about that
controller? I hear it all the time its too ugly, too big, too much like the
Dreamcast. Well, it isnt the prettiest thing, but it is damn comfortable. It does
look a bit like the DC controller from the top, but look at it from the side and
youll see a striking resemblance to the PS2 controller. In fact, the controller has
been designed to be completely ergonomic, and it feels better than any controller
Ive used. The buttons are well-placed, and the control just feels silky smooth.
Those nine foot long cables dont hurt, either finally, I can sit at a
comfortable distance from my TV and not have to move my console to the floor.
Lets see, is that all of it? Oh, the games. Thats right the games
are what count, right? You hear that mantra all the time. However, its difficult to
predict how good games will be, or even what titles well see for these systems in a
year or two. So on the one hand you have to pick a system that has games you want to play
now, but on the other, you kind of want to guess what system will have the best games in
the future. Undoubtedly, this is the PS2s strong suit, although its only been
recently that it has built a decent library. It took the PS2 a full year to really get
enough good games for people to risk it. Many folks were disappointed with the launch
lineup, and delays all the way through last spring and summer further saddened PS2 owners.
Finally we are seeing some truly great titles come out for the PS2.
The Xbox is launching with 19
titles, most of which will appeal to niche audiences. It does feature some really great
games, such as HALO and Munchs Oddysee. Fighting fans will dig DOA 3, and racing
fans will get their fix with a whole array of racing games: Project Gotham Racing, Test
Drive Off-Road, NASCAR Heat, and 4x4 Evo 2. Tony Hawks Pro Skater 2X gives die-hard
THPS fans a chance to see a new take on their old faves while they wait for THPS3 to come
to Xbox. Amped caters to the realistic snowboarding fans, and Dark Summit caters to the
SSX fans.
However, this is not the whole story. The gaming industry has become an environment
where publishers see more value in making games for all platforms rather than exclusively
supporting any single platform. This will only become more prevalent as developers and
publishers sink more money into their games they must recoup their costs as much as
possible. Think of it less like weve traditionally thought of ports and more as we
think of movies being released on both VHS and DVD. This means that most of the really
good third-party titles will be available on all systems. So the only games you really
need to worry about are first-party titles, developed and published by Sony or Microsoft.
Overall, as I said before,
youre not going to go wrong. All platforms will offer amazing gameplay and lots of
it. Gaming is becoming more and more mainstream every day, and the hardcore gamers will be
the folks with multiple systems. Sony is not going to go away, although I imagine they
will push development of the PS3 because the PS2 just isnt going to enjoy as long of
a lifespan as the PSone. Microsoft is here to stay they have vocally committed to
the console gaming market, and seek dominance. Will they get it? I dont know. I
would much prefer to see the market divided in three ways. Thats how the consumers
win we want choice and variety and we want these companies actively competing to
win our approval.
Lets face it, none of us stands to benefit or lose if any of these companies
succeed or fail. We only win if we get to play great games. In order for that to happen,
we need to support the good stuff and voice our disapproval of the bad. So while the
bickering and debates about which system is greater rage on this holiday season, keep in
mind that all of them have something to offer, and diversity of platforms will serve us
all well. Make friends with folks who have different systems and you will always have a
great game to play.